Marines furious at front-line 'pay cut'
The morale of Royal Marines serving on the front line in Afghanistan has plummeted after a £3,000 allowance was deducted from their wages following a "dreadful blunder" by Royal Navy administrators.
The revelation will come as an acute embarrassment for Tony Blair, who only last week was photographed among Royal Marines as he promoted Britain's strategy in the Taliban-ravaged country.
Politicians and Navy chiefs were so concerned over the impact of the wage cut that they sent extra human resources staff to Afghanistan to inform more than 1,000 commandos affected by the error.
The Marines had been told they could receive up to £17 extra a day as a special allowance for being on overseas operations during the six-month operation.
But they were misled and the Ministry of Defence has now refused to pay the extra £3,000 the men had been promised.
Some commandos in Afghanistan yesterday said they would consider resigning when they returned home because they were so disgusted with the MoD.
One troop commander said: "How is morale? It's absolutely dreadful out here. Some people, particularly senior NCOs, are going to lose out on a significant amount of money."
A senior NCO said: "This is another kick in the teeth just as we have deployed out here. We will do what we do job-wise, but this just shows the value the MoD places on our service."
The Daily Telegraph has obtained a letter from the Navy's second-in-command instructing senior officers on how to cope with the expected drop in morale.
Vice Admiral Adrian Johns, the Second Sea Lord, wrote that with 1,030 Marines in the lawless Helmand province being affected by the blunder, "this unfortunate error could not have materialised at a worse time".
He added: "The impact on our people will be acute and this issue has been considered at the highest level before deciding the way ahead."
"This issue will of course only affect those already serving in the front line units, but I have copied my letter to a wider audience in the knowledge that there will be some who are about to be drafted to sea and other operational areas and might already have an expectation of receiving more [money]."
"It is deeply regrettable that such an issue has arisen at a time when we have so many deployed on operations and careful management action will help to ensure that the inevitable disappointment for some is addressed in a considered manner."
Due to the complexity of new pay regulations and a "misinterpretation" of the rules, some personnel had been under an "erroneous expectation" they would receive extra daily allowances of between £1.04 and £16.74 a day depending on length of service.
The issue had been discussed with the Defence Secretary Des Browne and military chiefs but it was decided the Marines would not be given the promised money as a one-off payment.
This was "not what they may have been expecting" and commanders were instructed to tell their men "in as sensitive a manner as possible", the letter said.
"It is deeply regrettable that such an issue has arisen at a time when we have so many deployed on operations," the admiral concluded. "Careful management action will help to ensure that the inevitable disappointment for some is addressed in a considered manner."
Opposition politicians have accused the MoD of a "monumental cock-up" after it "effectively misled" more than 4,000 Marines and a smaller number of sailors.
Mark Harper, the shadow defence minister, said: "This will have a huge effect on morale for troops engaged in some of the most dangerous war-fighting for years, especially in the run up to Christmas. "The Defence Secretary really needs to get a grip and ensure it is the last time this type of thing happens. Our fighting troops deserve rather better than this."
The allowances were previously based on the number of days served in two areas called Qualifying Service and Paid Service. The troops were told these would both continue to be used to calculate the new Longer Separation Allowance.
This was incorrect as Qualifying Service days had never been counted under the new scheme. It was not until a few weeks ago that the Navy's Resources and Planning department noticed its mistake, but not before some marines had estimated their LSA bonuses at as much as 11 times beyond the level to which they were entitled.
The money is separate from the £2,240 tax free bonus being given to troops on operations announced by the Defence Secretary last month.
A senior Royal Navy officer said the error had been "absolutely devastating to morale".
"They are not being paid enough for what they do as it is so then to take £500 a month out of their pay is going to cause morale to plummet even further. Yes, they are incredibly dedicated people and love doing what they do out there, but this has made them incredibly unimpressed."
A Navy spokesman said it was "regrettable" that an error had been made when pay chiefs had incorrectly made briefings on pay allowances two years ago.
The new system was designed to simplify allowances and ensured Navy personnel were treated in the same way as RAF and Army.